I am reading a great book by Michael O'Brien, Harry Potter and the Paganization of Culture. This is my first Michael O'Brien book, and I must admit, I love his writing style and am looking forward to reading more, including his fiction.
In all honesty, it has been over ten years since I have read J.K. Rowling's series, and even then I only read the first three books. At the time, I found them mildly entertaining, but nothing that really stimulated me intellectually, so I never was too interested in reading more. As an avid reader and lover of adventure, I looked forward to the series when it was first released, but never really fell in love with the series like so many people did. And though I was not formed in my faith at all during that time, I was a bit unsettled when I read them, but I did not understand why.
No matter what side you are on in the debate over the Harry Potter books, O'Brien's take will open your eyes to so much more than what is superficially visible in reading J.K. Rowlings popular series. O'Brien presents his thoughts in a rational, thought provoking manner that touches on what is happening in our culture at large. In one section entitled "The pacification of the mind", he writes:
In his book, Amusing Ourselves to Death, media theorist and New York University professor Neil Postman describes how television has reshaped our society. In the past, when Western man moved from an oral culture to the print-dominated or "typographic" culture, significant changes resulted in our capacity to absorb experience and abstractions. The volume of information fed to the mind increased while the mind's ability to sort and evaluate the influx of data did not always keep pace. With the advent of television another quantum leap occurred. Flooded with powerful stimuli that bypassed the mind's normal faculties for filtering and interpretation, both the rational and the imaginative aspects of our minds became increasingly passive. As a result, Postman warns, our ways of perceiving reality itself are becoming fundamentally distorted. We now imbibe a massive amount of impressions in small bites that demand of us neither sustained attention nor truly critical thinking, thus rendering us vulnerable to manipulation. We are dangerously close, he says, to that condition described by Aldous Huxley in Brave New World. No longer conscious of our bondage we are soothed by endless entertainments.Ouch. That really hit home for me, being practically raised by the television (well, not really, but I did watch T.V. a lot growing up and it has somewhat formed me, for good and for bad). The good news is that I hardly watch television anymore. Every once in awhile I like to watch Journey Home on EWTN, but that is about it for me, except when coerced with popcorn by my dear hubby :). Unfortunately, about 90 percent of the conversations happening outside of my normal circle of friends revolve around television programming of which I have no input. The bad news is that I must admit to an internet addiction, so I can very much relate to what O'Brien says, "We now imbibe a massive amount of impressions in small bites that demand of us neither sustained attention nor truly critical thinking, thus rendering us vulnerable to manipulation." There is good and bad on the internet, and as a person who is in love with her faith and a very healthy appetite for learning more (virtue studiositas), I am quite often susceptible to crossing over into the vice of curiositas.
And there is music too. Sigh. I love music. Music is another form of entertainment that can evoke powerful memories and emotions. But with God's grace, He is helping me to seek the good, the true, and the beautiful of His creation. So much of my life has been formed by entertainment, but I am thankful for the grace of God's protection and bringing my heart to His, despite some of the bad influences I have had over the years. And I'm thankful for the gift of imagination and memory, now in light of a conscience being properly formed (it's still a work in progress). So why do I bring up music? Well, because I found this for your entertainment (!!!) by Roger Waters (I am a Pink Floyd fan), Amused to Death:
I, too, love music. However, having children really reshaped my musical selections. =]
ReplyDelete2 recommendations for you: 1) Matt Maher and, 2) Audrey Assad.
Both are Catholic and amazingly talented!
Peace!
Hi Kathryn,
ReplyDeleteThis is an excellent post. I was nodding my head the whole time. I'll have to get this book. I've always loved Michael O'Brien and didn't realize he had a non-fiction book out. Thanks for the heads up!