Pages

Saturday, August 13, 2011

Pilate's moral relativism

My husband is reading Life of Christ by Archbishop Fulton J. Sheen. The other night he read to me the following, His Excellency's reflections of Pilate's actions after asking Jesus "What is truth?" (John 18:38):

Then he turned his back on truth- better not on it, but on Him Who is Truth. It remained to be seen that tolerance of truth and error in a stroke of broadmindedness leads to intolerance and persecution; "What is truth?" when sneered, is followed up by the second sneer, "What is justice?" Broadmindedness, when it means indifference to right and wrong, eventually ends in a hatred of what is right. He who was so tolerant of error as to deny an Absolute Truth was the one who would crucify Truth. It was the religious judge who challenged Him, "I adjure thee"; but the secular judge asked, "What is truth?" He who was in the robe of the high priest called upon God to repudiate the things that are God's; he who was in the Roman toga just professed a skepticism and doubt.
and
Pilate was one of those who believed that truth was not objective but subjective, that each man determined for himself what was to be true. It is often the fault of practical men, such as Pilate, to regard the search for objective truth as useless theorizing. Skepticism is not an intellectual position; it is a moral position, in the sense that it is determined not so much by reason as by the way one acts and behaves. Pilate's desire to save Jesus was due to a kind of liberalism which combined disbelief in Absolute Truth with a half-benevolent unwillingness to disturb such dreamers and their superstitions. Pilate asked the question, "What is truth?" of the only Person in the world Who could answer it in all its fullness.


4 comments:

  1. I am reading this book myself ... and loving every single nugget of wisdom Sheen bestows on us.

    God Bless you!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello Michael, you put it so well, Sheen has so many nuggets of wisdom to give us! Everything he teaches is so relevant to what we are encountering today.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for this, I will look for this book. A dear relative of mine, an atheist, is enmeshed in relative-truth-thinking, and it is so difficult for me right now to deal with. She has turned her back on God and seems to be truly deaf and blind to what is most essential to my very existence. :(

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Joan, Archbishop Sheen is full of so much wisdom about this very subject! I have just started reading Life of Christ myself and I love watching reruns of his program on EWTN. Another book that we just got, but I have not read yet, is Render Unto Caesar by Archbishop Charles Chaput. I will pray for your friend and for conversion of her heart. Thanks for stopping by here.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you so much for stopping by and for your comment! Your comment will be posted after moderation.